Water retention is the property buyers most often pay for when they buy HPMC, so it is the one most worth measuring. It describes how well a fresh mortar holds its mixing water against suction from a porous substrate. Several test methods exist and they do not give comparable numbers, so a laboratory needs to choose one and use it consistently. This guide outlines the common methods and how to run a fair comparison between HPMC grades.
What is being measured
When fresh mortar is spread on a block wall or under a tile, the substrate draws water out by capillary suction. A mortar with good water retention resists this, so the cement or gypsum near the bond line has enough water to hydrate or crystallise. Laboratory tests reproduce the suction with a vacuum or with absorbent filter paper and measure how much water the mortar gives up or how its consistency changes.
Common methods
| Method | Principle | Result |
|---|---|---|
| ASTM C1506 | Mortar in a perforated dish is subjected to vacuum suction; flow is measured before and after | Water retention as a percentage based on retained flow |
| ASTM C1922 | Suction applied to mortar and the water lost is measured directly | Water retention by direct water loss |
| Vacuum filtration in a Büchner funnel (used in several national standards, e.g. GB/T 28627) | A thin mortar layer is held under defined vacuum for a set time | Percentage of water retained by mass |
| Filter paper methods (e.g. DIN 18555 Part 7 in older German practice) | Mortar placed in a ring on absorbent paper for a set time | Percentage of water retained, from paper weight gain |
ASTM C1506 notes that its result is based on mortar flow, while C1922 measures water loss directly. It also cautions that results do not necessarily represent field conditions, since absorption depends on the actual substrate.
A worked example from research
A study on HPMC in cement mortar used the vacuum filtration method: mortar was spread to 10 mm in a 150 mm Büchner funnel and held under a defined vacuum for 20 minutes. Water retention rose sharply as HPMC increased from 0.03% to 0.10% of cement mass, reaching about 92% at 0.10%, with smaller gains above that. The study also found that water retention tracked the mortar's plastic viscosity closely. It illustrates how the test can identify the point of diminishing returns for a given grade.
Running a fair comparison
- Fix the base mix. Use the same cement or gypsum, sand, fillers and other additives for every sample.
- Fix the water. Either use a constant water ratio or adjust water to constant consistency; record which, as the choice affects results.
- Control temperature. Condition materials and run tests at the standard laboratory temperature. HPMC behaviour changes with temperature, and above its gel temperature it loses much of its effect.
- Fix timings. Mixing time, rest time and test start must be identical, because surface-treated grades dissolve progressively.
- Repeat. Run at least duplicate tests and report the mean and spread.
- Test at more than one dosage. A grade that wins at one dosage may not at another.
Testing for hot conditions
Standard tests run at around 20 to 23 °C. If your products are used on hot walls or in summer conditions, add a check with materials and equipment conditioned at a higher temperature, or measure open time on a warm substrate. Grades with a higher gel temperature generally hold their performance better in heat.
Related tests
- Consistency (flow table or penetration) at the same time as water retention.
- Open time and tensile adhesion for tile adhesives.
- Setting time, since HPMC delays early hydration.
- Air content and density, as HPMC entrains some air.
Using results in purchasing
Water retention is a property of the mortar, not of the HPMC alone, so suppliers usually certify viscosity, moisture and ash rather than mortar water retention. Agree a qualification test in your own base mix for each new grade or supplier, then control incoming lots by viscosity and a periodic retention check. When requesting HPMC from Nuroil for construction chemical production, ask for a sample for qualification along with the CoA and technical data sheet.

