Formulators of shampoos, shower gels, hand washes and dishwashing liquids often thicken their products with nothing more than sodium chloride. It is cheap and effective, but it behaves in a way that surprises newcomers: add a little and the product thickens; keep adding and, past a certain point, it becomes thinner again. That rise and fall is known as the salt curve, and understanding it saves a lot of failed batches.
Why salt thickens SLES
In water, SLES molecules gather into clusters called micelles, with their oily tails inside and their charged sulphate heads facing the water. In a dilute solution these micelles are small and roughly spherical, so the liquid flows easily.
The charged heads repel each other, which keeps the micelles small. Adding salt supplies sodium and chloride ions that screen this repulsion. The heads can then pack more closely, and the micelles grow into long, flexible, worm-like structures. These tangle together like strands of cooked pasta, and the solution becomes much more viscous.
Why too much salt thins it again
As more salt is added, the worm-like micelles start to branch and connect to one another. A branched network can relax stress by sliding junctions along the micelles rather than by untangling, and viscosity falls. At still higher salt levels, the surfactant may begin to separate, giving a hazy or two-layer product. The result is a curve with a single peak: viscosity climbs, reaches a maximum and then drops.
The practical lesson is that when a product is too thin, more salt is not always the answer. If the batch is already past the peak, extra salt makes it thinner.
What moves the curve
- Degree of ethoxylation: SLES is made with an average number of ethylene oxide units, commonly 1, 2 or 3. Research on mixed surfactant systems shows that the salt level needed to reach peak viscosity depends on the average degree of ethoxylation. Lower ethoxylation generally thickens more readily with salt; higher ethoxylation is more water-soluble and less responsive.
- Co-surfactants: amphoteric surfactants such as betaines, and alkanolamides, strengthen thickening and shift the peak.
- Salt already present: SLES contains some sodium sulphate and sodium chloride from manufacture. Lots with different inorganic salt content start at different points on the curve.
- Fragrance, solvents and temperature: perfumes and solvents such as ethanol usually reduce viscosity, and viscosity falls as temperature rises.
- pH: changes in pH alter the charge on amphoteric co-surfactants and can move viscosity noticeably.
Building a salt curve in the laboratory
- Make the base formulation without salt, using the actual SLES lot that will go into production.
- Prepare a concentrated brine, for example a saturated sodium chloride solution.
- Split the base into a series of samples and add increasing amounts of brine, for example in steps of 0.25% salt on the total formula.
- Allow samples to stand until air bubbles have cleared and the temperature has settled.
- Measure viscosity at a fixed temperature, spindle and speed, and plot viscosity against salt.
- Choose a working salt level on the rising side of the peak, not at the very top, so that small variations do not push the batch over the edge.
Producers of SLES 70% recommend adding salt as a solution rather than as solid crystals, which dissolve unevenly and create local gel lumps.
| Symptom | Likely cause | What to try |
|---|---|---|
| Thin product, salt already high | Past the peak of the curve | Re-make with less salt or add more surfactant |
| Viscosity varies batch to batch | Different inorganic salt in SLES lots | Run a short salt curve on each new lot |
| Gel lumps after salting | Solid salt added directly | Add salt as brine with good mixing |
| Thinning after fragrance addition | Perfume disrupts micelles | Include fragrance when building the curve |
The salt curve belongs to the formula and the raw material lot, not to SLES in general. Check it whenever either changes.
What to ask from your SLES supplier
Consistent thickening starts with consistent raw material. Ask for the degree of ethoxylation, active matter range, sodium sulphate and sodium chloride limits, and a certificate of analysis with each delivery, so that lots can be compared before they go into production. For questions on SLES supply, contact Nuroil through the contact page.
