Buyers of SLES increasingly see a line for 1,4-dioxane on specification sheets and certificates of analysis, and some customers in the cosmetics and household sectors now set their own limits. This article explains, factually, what 1,4-dioxane is, why it appears in SLES, how it is reduced and how to handle it in purchasing.
What 1,4-dioxane is
1,4-dioxane is a small cyclic ether: a colourless, water-miscible liquid used in its own right as an industrial solvent. It is not added to SLES. It forms as a trace by-product when ingredients are made by ethoxylation, the process of attaching ethylene oxide units to a molecule. Regulators point to ingredients whose names include PEG, polyethylene glycol, polyoxyethylene, "-eth-" or "-oxynol-" as the types where it can occur. Sodium laureth sulphate falls into that group.
Health agencies treat 1,4-dioxane as a potential human carcinogen on the basis of animal studies, which is why levels in consumer products are monitored and limited.
How it forms in SLES manufacture
SLES is made in two main steps. First, a fatty alcohol is ethoxylated with ethylene oxide to make an alcohol ethoxylate. Second, the ethoxylate is sulphated, usually with sulphur trioxide, and neutralised with sodium hydroxide. 1,4-dioxane can form in both steps: as a side product of ethoxylation and, more significantly, through acid-catalysed reactions of the ethylene oxide chain during sulphation. Its amount depends on the degree of ethoxylation, the reaction temperature, contact time and how quickly the acid intermediate is neutralised.
How producers reduce it
- Process control in sulphation: tight control of the sulphur trioxide ratio, temperature and residence time, followed by prompt neutralisation, limits formation in the first place.
- Vacuum stripping: removing volatile 1,4-dioxane from the product under reduced pressure. Regulators have recommended this to manufacturers since the 1980s. It lowers, but does not entirely eliminate, residual levels.
- Raw material choice: lower degrees of ethoxylation and well-controlled ethoxylates give less opportunity for formation.
Monitoring surveys of finished cosmetics show the effect of these measures. Average levels found in products fell from tens of parts per million in early surveys to the point where a large majority of products tested in later surveys had none detectable at a 1 ppm detection limit.
How limits are set
Limits apply at two levels: the raw material and the finished product.
- Raw material: SLES producers state a maximum 1,4-dioxane content on their specifications. Published sheets for 70% grades commonly show limits in the range of about 20 to 50 ppm, with lower-dioxane grades available on request.
- Finished cosmetic products: the European Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety considered trace levels of up to 10 ppm in finished cosmetic products to be safe for consumers.
- Specific jurisdictions: some authorities have set legal maximum concentrations in finished goods. For example, New York State limits 1,4-dioxane to 1 ppm in household cleansing and personal care products and 10 ppm in cosmetics.
Translating raw material limits into product levels
A finished product's contribution from SLES can be estimated from the raw material level and the dose. For example:
| SLES 70% in formula | Dioxane in SLES | Estimated contribution in product |
|---|---|---|
| 15% | 30 ppm | 4.5 ppm |
| 15% | 10 ppm | 1.5 ppm |
| 15% | 5 ppm | 0.75 ppm |
Other ethoxylated ingredients in the formula add to the total, so the brand owner should work out the full budget. This simple arithmetic shows why buyers serving markets with strict limits specify low-dioxane SLES.
1,4-dioxane is a process by-product, not an ingredient. Specify a maximum, ask for the test result on every lot, and budget for the whole formula.
Testing
1,4-dioxane is measured by gas chromatography, usually with headspace sampling and mass spectrometric detection. Results depend on the method and laboratory, so agree the method and detection limit with your supplier, and use the same laboratory when comparing lots.
Specifying it in an enquiry
State the maximum 1,4-dioxane level you need on the raw material, the test method, and whether you require the result on each certificate of analysis. Nuroil supplies SLES on request with a CoA for every delivery, and third-party inspection can be arranged. Send your specification through the quote form.
