Very low sulphur fuel oil (VLSFO), with a maximum of 0.50% sulphur, became the main residual marine fuel when the global sulphur limit took effect in 2020. Unlike traditional high sulphur fuel oil, VLSFO is often blended from quite different refinery streams to reach its sulphur limit. That makes stability within a batch and compatibility between batches a practical concern for every ship's engine department.
Stability and compatibility are not the same
- Stability is a single fuel's ability to keep its heavy asphaltene molecules dispersed rather than letting them drop out as sludge, during storage, heating and handling.
- Compatibility is whether two fuels, each stable on its own, stay stable when mixed. Two good fuels can produce sludge when combined.
Why VLSFO is more sensitive
Residual fuels hold asphaltenes in suspension because of a balance with aromatic components that act as solvents. Many VLSFOs are made by blending low-sulphur residues with paraffinic components such as hydrotreated gasoils or other light, low-aromatic streams. Paraffinic material has little ability to keep asphaltenes in solution. If a highly aromatic fuel with a lot of asphaltenes meets a highly paraffinic fuel, the solvent balance can tip and the asphaltenes flocculate into a sticky sludge.
Because VLSFO recipes vary from port to port and even between deliveries from the same supplier, a ship cannot assume that a new batch will mix happily with what is already on board.
What incompatibility looks like in practice
- Rapid blocking of fuel filters and frequent backflushing.
- Heavy sludge loading on separators (purifiers), sometimes overwhelming them.
- Sludge deposits in settling and service tanks.
- In severe cases, fuel starvation and engine shutdown.
Tests that help
| Test | What it shows | Limitations |
|---|---|---|
| Total sediment potential, TSP (ISO 10307-2) | Sediment after ageing the fuel at 100°C for 24 hours; indicates the fuel's own stability reserve | Laboratory test; results usually take more than a day |
| Total sediment accelerated, TSA (ISO 10307-2) | Sediment after chemical ageing; faster indicator | Can read low for some VLSFOs where TSP is high, so TSP is preferred as the referee |
| Spot test (ASTM D4740) | A heated drop of a blend on filter paper, rated against reference spots, shows whether sediment rings form | Quick and can be done on board, but paraffinic fuels can give misleading results |
The ISO 8217 limit for total sediment aged in residual fuels is 0.10% by mass. A fuel that meets this limit on its own is stable, but that alone says nothing about how it will behave when mixed with another fuel.
Good practice on board
- Segregate new deliveries. Load each new VLSFO batch into empty tanks wherever possible, and avoid topping up tanks holding a different batch.
- Wait for the analysis. Use the new batch only after the laboratory result confirms it meets specification, unless operations make this impossible.
- Test before you must mix. If commingling cannot be avoided, run a compatibility test on representative samples of both fuels in the expected ratio first.
- Minimise mixing during changeover. When switching from one batch to another, run down the service tank as far as is safe so that the mixing zone is small.
- Watch the separators. Increase monitoring of filters and purifier sludge discharge after starting a new batch.
Similar density and viscosity are sometimes used as a rough indicator that two fuels will be compatible, but this is not reliable and should not replace a test.
Treat every VLSFO delivery as a new fuel: keep it separate until it has been tested, and test again before mixing it with anything else.
What to ask for when buying VLSFO
Specify the ISO 8217 grade and edition, and request that total sediment potential is reported on the supplier's quality certificate. Ask for density, viscosity and, where available, aromaticity indicators so the engine department can judge how the new fuel compares with what is on board. Plan tank space so that the delivery can be segregated. Nuroil can supply VLSFO on request; see the bunker and marine fuel page for details.


